Purchase Protection included
Easy access to support
Secure, flexible payment options
Mystery Mail Subscription by My Paper Box
You never know what kind of paper joy you’ll unwrap!
Secure checkout
Purchase Protection
Cancel anytime
Last Minute Gift? No worries.
Shipping Policy
-
Estimated ship date: July 8
-
Ships from United States
Your first Mystery My Paper Box ships right after you subscribe—no waiting! Future boxes renew and ship on the same date each month as your original signup, keeping your surprises perfectly on schedule.
Cancellation & Refund Policy
- for questions about your box
- Subscriptions automatically renew. You can cancel at any time.
About this seller
My Paper Box
Responds within 24h
Tracked shipping
Every box ships from United States with tracking included.
Direct messaging
Reach the seller directly with any pre-purchase questions.
Purchase Protection
If your box doesn't arrive or isn't as described, Cratejoy has your back.
Reviews for this item
Be the first to review this box
No reviews yet for Mystery Mail Subscription by My Paper Box. Once you receive your first box from My Paper Box, share what you thought — your review helps other subscribers decide.
Buyer highlights:
4.7
Photos from reviews
142 photos and 18 videos from real subscribers
Top reviews from customers
-
May Sub Box
This month was great. Love the bright colors. I am so glad I started this subscription again.
5 5 -
5 stars! ✨
Lovely stationary box with high quality cards, notepads and stickers! The illustrations are beautiful! I just renewed my subscription and highly recommend this awesome subscription!
5 5 -
Best Decision of 2022!!!
This is my favorite decision of 2022! I get so so so many compliments on the stationary and have already found so many uses for the cards and such. These boxes are so cute and well thought out. I can't get enough! I have been recommending t
5 5 -
Life time buyer
I am very excited every month for the next My Paper Box doing reviews so you don't have too... YouTube Silkyfeather, The are always with top product. I love you My Paper Box! Life time buyer!
5 5 -
Stationary junkie approved!
So perfect and fun!
5 5
Product Details
Stationery Surprises Delivered - Unwrap the Mystery — Discover What My Paper Box Has in Store!
Can’t pick just one favorite? Let us surprise you! Each Mystery Mail box is packed with a hand-selected assortment of My Paper Box products from past collections — think notepads, greeting cards, stickers, and stationery surprises. Every box is unique and full of MPB magic!No personalization, just pure fun. Perfect for gift-giving, trying out our products, or stocking up your desk stash.
- A surprise mix of past My Paper Box favorites — no two boxes are alike!
- Includes stationery, notepads, greeting cards, stickers, and other MPB goodies.
- Perfect for gifts, desk refreshes, or sampling our paper treasures.
- Ships immediately after purchase — no waiting for the next month’s box!
- Designed and packed with love in Austin, Texas.
More from My Paper Box
Personalized Stationery Subscription Box
Hi! I'm Sam, the designer behind My Paper Box. Every collection is illustrated, designed, printed, packed, and shipped from our Austin, Texas studio.
From
$33.33 / box
Monthly Personalized Notepad Club
A monthly personalized notepad with a fresh themed design every month. Perfect for daily lists, notes, and planning. Handmade in Austin.
From
$8.33 / box
Mystery Box
A surprise box filled with thoughtfully designed stationery and paper goods. Each box is a unique mix of past favorites, exclusive designs, and creative extras—no two are exactly the same.
$30.00
My Paper Box appears in these collections…
Mystery Mail Subscription by My Paper Box
by My Paper Box
Free Shipping